I Was Never Her First Choice

CH. 01

Chapter 1

20,242 words

Throughout our four years of college, Charlotte Montgomery booked train tickets for me and my buddy, Forrest Croft, whenever we headed back to school or went home for break.

She always claimed that getting tickets was a race against the clock, and somehow, the three of us never managed to sit together.

Every time the tickets were issued, Forrest would tear into her in our group chat.

"Charlotte, can you be any more useless? You managed to book three tickets in three different train cars. Next time, you'd better stand right next to him, even if you have to stand the whole way. Otherwise, you'll answer to me."

Charlotte always fired back immediately.

"Who the hell do you think you are? I could crouch at his feet, and it still wouldn't be any of your business."

I believed them.

Even when I spent six hours sitting alone in an uncomfortable seat, or came down with a fever in the middle of the night and called Charlotte more than a dozen times without getting an answer, I assumed she'd fallen asleep in another train car.

It wasn't until our graduation trip, when someone asked to switch seats with me.

I dragged my suitcase over, only to find Forrest with my jacket draped over his shoulders, his head resting on Charlotte's shoulder as they shared a pair of earbuds.

When Charlotte saw me, she simply pulled out one earbud and sat up straight.

"Let's get one thing straight. We've always been careful not to give people the wrong idea. I only kept it from you because I was afraid you'd feel uneasy if you knew we'd be sitting next to each other for six hours."

Forrest patted the seat beside him.

"I'm your buddy. Isn't it better to have me keep an eye on your girlfriend, rather than some random guy sitting next to her?"

Just then, a smiling train attendant came over and handed them a matching set of luggage tags.

"According to our system, you two have sat next to each other on all 16 round trips throughout your four years at college. We'd like to give you this souvenir to commemorate that."

Only after she'd finished speaking did she notice me. She glanced down at the booking details again.

"This is your friend who booked tickets with you, too, right? How come he's the one sitting alone every time, even though all three of you book your tickets together?"

The entire train car fell silent.

I looked at Charlotte's pale face, realizing something. They had never once been separated from each other.

For four years, I'd been left out every single time.

Chapter 1 The Sixteenth Trip

The train car fell silent for a few seconds.

Forrest was the first to speak, his voice tinged with amusement.

"Don't look at us like that. Charlotte thought you'd overthink things. She was afraid you'd have trouble sleeping if you knew we were sitting next to each other, so she told me not to tell you about it."

I looked at the jacket draped over his shoulders.

Before we left, Charlotte had taken it out of my suitcase. She said the air conditioning on the train was cold, and she didn't want me catching a chill.

Yet in the end, she'd put it over Forrest.

I stared at Charlotte, my voice hoarse. "So, you lied to me 16 times?"

Charlotte lowered her voice. "Enough. Everyone's watching. Do you really have to make a scene on the train?"

Meanwhile, Forrest was already on his feet. He brushed at his clothes and smiled as he offered me his seat. "Fine. You two can sit together. Besides, Charlotte and I have done this 16 times already. What's one more trip?"

As he straightened up, the headphone cable connecting them was pulled loose.

She immediately grabbed his wrist. "You don't need to move."

Then, she turned to me. "Go sit next to the person you switched seats with earlier for now. Quit blocking the aisle and giving everyone a show."

My whole body felt numb, and I couldn't move.

Charlotte reprimanded sternly, "He gets motion sickness. Sitting in an unfamiliar seat makes him uncomfortable."

Even the train attendant awkwardly reminded me to move aside.

With no other choice, I sat in the empty seat behind them. Forrest settled back into his seat and picked up his headphones.

I turned my head, only to notice a thick scrapbook on their table. Its cover was plastered with train tickets.

Following my gaze, Forrest picked it up. "Since you've found out, we might as well take another picture for the collection."

He pulled a Polaroid camera from his bag, aimed it at me, and snapped a photo.

Before I could react, the picture had already slid out.

In the picture, my face was pale, my hair was mussed from the luggage brushing against it, and I was sitting beside the aisle looking so disheveled I was almost unrecognizable.

Forrest laughed as he stuck the photo onto the last page. "This one's especially meaningful. Our 16th trip, and we finally got caught."

Then, he raised the camera again and leaned toward Charlotte. "Come on. Let's get a picture of the real mastermind."

Charlotte said it was silly, but she leaned toward him anyway.

The flash went off.

In the photo, he smiled brightly, while she wore a slight smile of her own.

He stuck the two pictures side by side, then turned the scrapbook toward me.

"I was going to give this to you two after graduation. When you get married someday, it'll be a keepsake from your college years."

I flipped back through the earlier pages.

Sixteen trips. Hundreds of photos.

They'd taken pictures of themselves eating instant noodles together. They'd even taken pictures of Charlotte falling asleep against his shoulder.

Beside the photos were handwritten notes from the two of them.

"Winter break, sophomore year. She slept for five hours and let me use her shoulder the whole time."

"Start of junior year. Someone grumbled about it, but still refilled my hot-water bottle three times when my stomach hurt."

Yet after four years of dating Charlotte, I barely had any pictures with her.

Whenever I raised my phone to take one, she'd frown. "We see each other every day. What's there to take pictures of?"

Once, I begged her for so long that she finally agreed to take one with me.

As soon as we took the photo, she told me to delete it. She said she didn't like keeping photos.

It turned out she just didn't want any with me.

Chapter 2 The Final Straw

My fingers loosened, and the scrapbook slipped from my hands. The photos inside scattered across the floor.

Forrest immediately bent down to pick them up.

Charlotte's expression darkened. "If you don't want to look, then don't. Why'd you have to throw them? Forrest spent four years putting all this together."

I stared at the photos scattered across the floor.

"What about me? What about the time I had a fever and was all alone? I called you more than a dozen times. You didn't answer because you were with him taking these pictures, weren't you?"

Charlotte's hands paused for a moment. Then, she frowned again. "How long ago was that?"

She crouched down to help Forrest gather the photos.

With their heads lowered, they sorted them out one by one. Neither of them looked at me again.

Just then, my phone vibrated.

My mother had sent me a message. "Once your graduation trip is over, it's time to make a decision. Are you coming home with us, or are you still relocating to another city with Charlotte?"

I'd already drafted my answer two weeks ago. "Charlotte and I have already agreed to live together after graduation. We're going to be happy!"

The message had been sitting in the text box ever since.

I stared at it for a long time before deleting it, one word at a time.

The train pulled into the station, and everyone stood up at once. The aisle quickly filled with people.

As soon as Forrest got to his feet, someone behind him bumped into him.

Charlotte immediately reached out to shield him, keeping him between herself and the seat. "Don't move. Let's wait until the crowd thins out."

The crowd pushed me backward. My shoulder slammed into the luggage rack, leaving it numb with pain.

She saw what happened, but all she did was remind Forrest, "Hold on to me. Don't fall."

…

By the time I finally got off the train, I remembered that both suitcases were still in the car we'd been in.

One of them was full of clothes and toiletries Forrest had packed last minute. His own suitcase was too full, so he made me carry his things the entire journey.

I fought my way back through the crowd and hauled both heavy suitcases off the train.

…

By the time I made it out of the station, it was pouring.

Charlotte and Forrest were nowhere to be seen.

There was only one message from her on my phone. "Forrest is so hungry his stomach hurts, so we've headed to the restaurant first. You're taking too long. Just get a cab here."

Rain streamed from my hair.

I stood outside an unfamiliar train station with a suitcase in each hand.

My phone lit up again. My mother was asking if I'd made up my mind.

I looked down at the empty text box where my message had been.

This time, I didn't hesitate. "I'll come home with you after the trip, Mom."

Still, I'd been wanting to visit this city for a long time. I wasn't going to give up a trip I'd been looking forward to for three months just because of Charlotte and Forrest.

I called a cab outside the station and went to the hotel alone.

The suitcases were so heavy that the driver helped me unload them. He couldn't help asking, "Where are your friends? Why are you carrying all this stuff by yourself?"

I didn't answer.

The hotel restaurant was right beside the lobby.

Through the glass, I spotted Charlotte and Forrest immediately. They were sitting side by side in a booth.

Forrest snatched the drink out of Charlotte's hand and took a sip through the straw. Charlotte shoved his head away in annoyance, but he kicked her feet playfully.

Laughing, he leaned against her shoulder, but she didn't push him away.

I dragged my suitcases inside.

She saw me first, and the smile vanished from her face.

He straightened up too. He put the drink back in front of her and deliberately put some distance between them.

Just then, the elevator doors opened.

A few classmates came down, laughing and chatting.

When they saw how deliberately far apart Charlotte and Forrest were sitting, they immediately started laughing. "What's with the act? He's not even here."

The speaker turned around and finally noticed me standing at the entrance. His smile froze.

Another guy hadn't caught on yet. "Weren't you two practically glued together at every get-together he missed? Remember New Year's Eve? Charlotte got drunk, and Forrest slept with his head on her arm all night."

His friends frantically tugged at him. He finally realized something was off and fell silent.

Charlotte's expression darkened.

Forrest scooted back over to her and slung an arm around her neck. "There's no point pretending anymore. He's already found out, so we might as well lay it all out."

He jerked his chin toward me. "Actually, I told Charlotte when you two first started dating that we should all just treat each other like buddies and keep hanging out like we always had.

"But she insisted you were sensitive and would get the wrong idea if you saw us messing around, so I played along with her for four years."

He patted Charlotte on the shoulder. "There's nothing going on between us. We've done nothing wrong. Are we supposed to stop being friends just to spare your feelings?"

A few of our classmates chimed in, trying to smooth things over.

"They've always been like this throughout college. Don't make such a big deal out of it."

"Forrest is just an easygoing guy. If there were something between them, he wouldn't be acting like this now."

I looked at all those familiar faces.

Whenever they got together in the past, they always had an excuse for leaving me out, whether it was claiming there weren't enough seats or saying the plans had changed at the last minute.

On our dates, Charlotte would tell me she hadn't gone either.

Now, I finally realized she'd been at every single gathering I'd been left out of.

Chapter 3 Four Years of Habit

Charlotte dragged my suitcases aside and said coldly, "Everyone's trying to explain it to you. You can't just come in here with an attitude."

I ignored her, picked up my bag, and headed upstairs.

She hurried into the elevator just before the doors closed.

We were alone.

She wrapped her arms around me from behind, resting her forehead against my back. "Are you still mad? It's my fault for what happened on the train. Those people were running their mouths. Don't take what they said to heart."

I tried to pull away, but she only tightened her embrace.

"Your clothes are soaked. Why didn't you change into dry ones first? I've got the room key. There's warm tea and cold medicine on the table. Have some tea and take your medicine after your shower. Get some early rest tonight, okay?"

My nose suddenly stung.

Four years of habit weren't easy to break.

When the elevator reached our floor, Charlotte took my hand and led me to our room. She slipped a key card into my palm.

"By the way, we switched rooms."

I looked down. This wasn't the king room we'd originally booked for the trip. It was the windowless single room at the end of the hall.

Charlotte spoke matter-of-factly. "The AC in Forrest's room broke, and he's having stomach issues again. This is the only room the hotel has left. I let him have our king room, so you'll stay here tonight."

I looked up at her. "Then, where are you staying?"

"I'll sleep on the couch over there. When his stomach acts up, he tends to throw up in the middle of the night. If I sleep there, I can still keep an eye on him. It's just one night. We can switch back tomorrow if another room opens up."

She squeezed my hand. "I know you don't like all the hassle, and I'm not asking you to take care of him. This room may be small, but it's quiet. You can get some proper rest."

I looked at the key card in my hand and let out a brief laugh. "Sure."

Charlotte visibly relaxed. "I knew you wouldn't make a big deal out of something so—"

I cut her off. "But don't you think it's inappropriate for you and Forrest to be staying together like this, just the two of you?"

Her brows furrowed immediately. "Why bring this up again? Can you stop making everything sound so filthy?"

I nodded. "Why don't we just break up? It would make more sense for you to take care of him."

Charlotte's patience finally ran out. "All this over one room? You've been making a scene the entire trip. Haven't you had enough? Will you be happy only when everyone has to bend over backward to accommodate you?"

I swiped the key card and walked inside.

Charlotte reached out to stop me, but I shut the door. The door struck the back of her hand.

From outside, she called my name in a low voice. "Aiden, think this through. Breaking up isn't something you threaten someone with."

I leaned against the door and slowly loosened my grip on the key card.

This time, I'd given it plenty of thought.

Chapter 4 He Was Already Gone

The next morning, I stepped out of my room and found Charlotte and Forrest waiting by the elevator.

Charlotte's expression was cold. She was clearly still angry about me threatening to break up with her.

Forrest, however, gave her a playful nudge. "Come on. He was angry and said it in the heat of the moment. Are you really going to hold it against your boyfriend?"

Then, he slung an arm around my shoulders. "I've been trying to smooth things over with her all morning. She finally agreed to stop being mad."

She picked up where he left off. "Fine. I'll let last night's argument slide for Forrest's sake. Just don't threaten to break up with me over every little thing."

I glanced at her but said nothing.

Our itinerary for the day included the old town, the museum, and the riverside night market. These were the places I wanted to visit when planning the trip.

I had arranged to take pictures with Charlotte at every stop. Yet, when we reached the old town, she joined Forrest in line for a limited-edition milk tea beverage.

At the museum, she complained about the crowds and sat by the entrance to watch Forrest's bag.

I didn't wait for them.

I followed the map on my own, collected every commemorative stamp, and asked a passerby to take a picture of me by the river.

The wind was strong, but for once, I looked genuinely relaxed in the photo.

It suddenly occurred to me that maybe having Charlotte by my side wasn't as important as I'd thought.

…

When we met up at noon, she was still frowning. "You just wander off without telling anyone?"

Forrest stepped in to smooth things over. "It isn't often he gets to do this. Come on, give him a break. Besides, I'll keep you company. You won't get lost."

Charlotte shot him a glare, but the tension in her expression eased.

Just then, her phone rang. It was a video call from her mother, Jane Montgomery.

Forrest casually answered the call and greeted her cheerfully. "Hi, Mrs. Montgomery!"

Jane hadn't realized I was there, and she immediately began speaking. "Forrest, make sure you and Charlotte have a good time on this trip. And I've got some good news for you. I've already put in a word with the company. The position is being held for you."

Charlotte's expression changed. "Mom, stop."

Only then did Jane notice me on the screen. She paused, and her smile faded. "Oh, you're there too."

I said nothing.

Charlotte hurriedly ended the call. After a few seconds of silence, she seemed to decide to tell me the truth.

"Actually, there's something I forgot to tell you. There's only one referral slot in Riverdale this year. Forrest's grades aren't as good as yours, so he'd have a hard time landing the position on his own.

"He can have that position. You're capable enough to land another job."

Charlotte didn't give me a chance to respond before continuing, "Another thing about the apartment. Forrest will be joining Riverdale, but won't have anywhere to stay when he first arrives. The apartment we're renting has two bedrooms, so he'll take the smaller one for now.

"You can have the master bedroom, and he'll take the second bedroom. It's no big deal."

Forrest immediately clapped his hands. "Awesome! We can still live under the same roof after graduation!"

He winked at me. "Don't worry, I know when to give you two some space. I won't get in the way of your time together. When you shut the bedroom door to have some time alone, I promise I won't knock."

A few people nearby laughed.

I couldn't bring myself to smile.

I found that apartment and paid the security deposit myself. I even picked out the living room couch and bedroom curtains myself.

Now, with just a few words, they'd handed my job opportunity to Forrest and made room for him in my home.

At first, I was so furious that my fingers trembled. However, looking at how casually they took it all for granted, my anger suddenly faded. "Fine."

Charlotte assumed I'd agreed, and her expression softened. "If you'd been this reasonable from the start, we wouldn't have had that fight last night."

I looked at her, my voice calm. "We've already broken up. What you two do is none of my business. Just make sure you pay me back for the money I put down for the apartment."

Forrest reached out to stop me. "Don't do anything rash. I'll give up the position, okay?"

But she stopped him. "If you go after him and give in now, he'll threaten to leave whenever he doesn't get his way. You can't keep encouraging that kind of behavior."

I didn't look back.

I'd already visited every place I'd wanted to see that day, so I booked a ticket home for that afternoon.

…

That evening, Charlotte returned to the hotel carrying a limited-edition plush toy sold only in the city, something I'd once casually mentioned wanting.

She lingered at the front desk for a moment before trying to sound nonchalant. "I'm not trying to make it up to him. I just bought it on a whim. Could you ask him to come down and get it?"

The receptionist looked puzzled. "You mean the young man staying in the windowless room? He checked out this afternoon. His family sent a car to pick him up, and he took all his luggage with him."

Charlotte's expression froze.

Then, the receptionist seemed to remember something. "Oh, right. He asked me to pass along a message before he left. He doesn't want the room, the job, or you anymore."

The rest of the manuscript

The sample pages stop here.

Not yet catalogued

This is a catalogue, not a library. Each entry records what the publisher told us about a title — author, length, status — together with any sample chapters they allow to be read here. For the manuscript itself we point you to the official reading app; nothing beyond the samples is stored on this site.