CH. 01
Chapter 1
When my sister, Aubrey Kirkland, called, she was crying.
"Opal, I'm so sorry... I think I hit your daughter with my car."
I rushed to the school entrance and Aubrey threw herself into my arms at once.
"She ran out of nowhere. I swear I didn't mean to."
My parents hurried to her side.
"Aubrey, honey, are you hurt?"
Garrick Fenmore arrived right after them. He pulled Aubrey behind him and spoke to her in a low, soothing voice.
"Don't be scared. I'm here, and nobody is going to make you take the blame."
I froze. This was not right. Why was everyone's first concern the person who had hit the child?
Besides, my daughter had not gone to school at all this week.
Then who had been killed?
Chapter 1
My thumb had barely pressed the emergency number when Garrick Fenmore snatched the phone out of my hand.
"Don't call yet."
I froze for half a second, then tried to grab it back. "Give that back!"
"If an ambulance comes, the police come with it."
He shifted sideways to block my view of the crumpled white sedan and lowered his voice. "You want to send Aubrey to prison before we even know what happened?"
I stared at him in disbelief.
A child was lying on the ground.
She wore a gray school uniform and white sneakers. A jacket covered her body, leaving only part of her wrist exposed.
The right side of the car's front end was caved in, yet the skid marks were pitifully short.
I was an auto insurance claims adjuster and I knew better than any of them what had to happen next. We had to save the child, call the police and preserve the scene, not make excuses for the driver.
"Whether we know what happened or not, that child needs help right now." I forced down the tremor in my voice. "If Aubrey did something wrong, she has to take responsibility for it."
Garrick held the phone up out of my reach. "She's not breathing anymore. There's no saving her. Calling the police will just get Aubrey locked up."
"I checked her pulse. She still has one."
My sister, Aubrey Kirkland, huddled in Mom's arms, sobbing so hard her whole body shook. "Opal, I only glanced down at the GPS for a second, and she just ran out in front of me—"
Dad immediately stepped in front of her. "Aubrey is terrified enough already. Stop upsetting her!"
"Dad." My eyes stung as I stared at him.
"That is a living human being lying over there. Are you really going to stand by and watch her die just to keep Aubrey out of prison?"
His face stiffened for a moment before he looked away.
Mom patted Aubrey's back and said impatiently, "Do you think any of us feel good about this? Your sister is young, though, and she just started a new job. If the police take her away, her whole life will be ruined!"
They had arrived believing the child was my daughter, Clover Fenmore. If it truly had been Clover, would they still have acted this way?
My tears finally fell.
"Aubrey's whole life matters, but Clover's doesn't?"
Nobody answered.
Whenever Aubrey cried, they all rushed to her side. It had been that way since we were kids.
When she broke my trophy, it was my fault for not putting it away. When she tore up my college acceptance letter, I was being petty. When she took my wedding venue, I was supposed to be understanding because of her poor health.
Even on my wedding day, when she took the wrong medication after a breakup, Garrick abandoned a room full of guests and stayed by her side at the hospital all night.
Time and again, I had told myself that they loved me, and that their love for my sister was simply an extension of it.
Only today did I understand that the favored one could trample even another person's life underfoot.
I turned and headed for the stationery store by the road.
Garrick chased after me and seized my arm. "Where are you going?"
"To borrow a phone and call the police."
"Opal Kirkland!"
He blocked the doorway, his expression dark. "Are you really determined to tear this family apart?"
I looked at his anxious face, and my chest ached as though a dull knife were sawing back and forth inside it.
When Clover had a high fever, he had said he was busy with work. When I had my appendix removed, he had been helping Aubrey pick out a new home after her divorce.
Now that Aubrey had hit someone, he had driven through the night from out of town to shield her from every consequence.
My eyes burned as I asked, "What if the child who got hit was Aubrey's daughter, Bonnie? Would you still stop me from calling the police?"
Garrick's throat bobbed. After a moment, he said quietly, "This has nothing to do with whose kid it is. Even if it were Bonnie, I wouldn't let you lose your head, call the police, and ruin your sister's life."
My hand slowly dropped to my side.
From his perspective, even Clover's death was not worth as much as Aubrey's future.
"Fine," I said hoarsely, stepping back.
While his guard was down, I took my backup work phone out of my jacket's inside pocket and dialed the police.
Chapter 2
Garrick's face changed and he lunged for the phone.
I quickly backed into a stationery store.
The shop owner took one look at the child outside, locked the glass door at once, and stepped in front of me.
"Don't be scared, miss. I called the police too and an ambulance is on its way."
Outside, Aubrey collapsed onto the ground.
Mom cried out at me through the glass. "Opal, how can you be so heartless? Aubrey is your sister! Can you really stand to watch her go to prison?"
I clenched my jaw and gave the dispatcher the time and location of the accident, along with details about the vehicle.
"The victim appears to be a girl around seven years old. Her identity can't be confirmed yet."
After I hung up, I looked again at the hand sticking out from under the jacket. A pink and white bunny bracelet was tied around the wrist.
My breath was stuck in my throat.
I had made that bracelet for Clover with my own hands. After she learned to string beads, she had pestered me for days until I made it for her. There was only one like it in the whole world.
I shoved the door open and ran outside. I knelt beside the jacket, my hand hovering in midair, but I could not bring myself to lift it.
"Opal, I called you because I recognized the bracelet," Aubrey said, choking back sobs. "I don't want to believe it's Clover either..."
"That's impossible." I shook my head frantically, tears splashing onto the pavement. "Clover has the flu. She hasn't been to school all week. I took her temperature this morning before I left."
I immediately called her kids' smartwatch, but no one answered.
Clover's nanny, Martha Quigley, had her phone switched off as well.
The hope that had just risen in me slowly sank.
Garrick came to my side and said quietly, "I dropped Clover off at school this morning."
My head snapped up. "Weren't you away on a business trip?"
"The meeting ended early, so I got back in the middle of the night. She said she was feeling better and didn't want to keep missing class, so I brought her here."
"What time? Which entrance?"
"7:40am. This side gate."
I stared hard at him, my voice shaking uncontrollably. "You saw her go in with your own eyes?"
His gaze flickered away for an instant before he nodded. "I did."
The last shred of hope shattered. I staggered back, and Garrick reached out to steady me.
I shook him off and lunged for the jacket, desperate to see the child's face.
Aubrey grabbed me from behind. "Opal, don't look! The side of her face is badly hurt. You won't be able to handle it!"
My body went rigid, and a choked sob escaped my throat.
Dad crouched down and tucked the jacket back into place, insisting that no one should disturb the scene.
In the next breath, he turned and quietly asked Aubrey, "Can the dashcam footage be deleted?"
Aubrey hesitated. "I think so."
I pushed myself up off the ground and wiped away my tears.
"I'll report anyone who deletes it for intentionally destroying evidence."
Dad angrily blocked the car door. "There are no outsiders here. Don't try to scare your own family with that work nonsense!"
I pointed at the child on the ground, my voice rising sharply. "What is she, then? A nobody?"
The wail of a siren grew closer. I ran to the side of the road to wave the ambulance in.
A paramedic checked the child's pupils and the pulse in her neck, then looked up at a partner and gave a small shake of the head.
My legs gave out, and I nearly fell to my knees.
Garrick caught me by the shoulders and spoke with a gentleness he rarely showed. "Opal, don't look anymore. Honestly, it's better that it's our child. At least we won't have to deal with outsiders."
I had waited so long for him to speak to me that gently. Now it only sent a chill through me.
Chapter 3
The paramedics declared the child brain-dead. There was nothing more they could do.
Before the police arrived, Garrick pulled me aside.
"Aubrey is in shock, so her story might not line up perfectly. When the police question you, don't get hung up on the details."
Aubrey nodded at once. "Right, I was so scared I got confused. Opal, there aren't any cameras here. As long as you don't say the wrong thing, I won't go to prison."
I finally understood. They had called me here so I would lie to the police for Aubrey.
"Aubrey, that is a human life. Is Clover really someone you can just throw away?"
Dad pressed a bank card into my hand. "There's 300,000 dollars on this. Whether that child is Clover or not, the family will take care of you."
I looked down at the card, and my tears slowly stopped.
When I was little, Aubrey had pushed me down the stairs, and I needed eight stitches in my forehead. They bought me a dress and told me to say I had fallen on my own.
All these years, they had believed my pain came with a price tag.
I snapped the card in half right in front of him and tossed it into the trash can.
Dad's face flushed red with anger. "Did we raise you all these years so you could kick your family when they're down?"
"She hit my daughter! You want me to give up on Clover just to protect your other daughter?"
He roared, "Clover may be your daughter, but Aubrey is your sister! Are you really going to send your own sister to prison?"
Garrick cut in. "I'm Clover's father and I get half the say. I'm not letting the police dig into how she died."
My chest tightened, but I did not cry again. I turned and photographed the car, the skid marks and the road signs.
The right front tire had fresh scrape marks, and the skid marks were extremely short. Aubrey had most likely been speeding.
A backpack lay at the side of the road with a strawberry keychain hanging from it.
It was not Clover's.
Before I could take a closer look, Mom snatched it up and clutched it to her chest. "Stop taking pictures! She's already dead. What good is any of this going to do?"
"Give it to me. That's evidence."
Mom's eyes darted nervously, and she held it even tighter.
Aubrey suddenly pressed a hand to her chest and doubled over, gasping for air. "Mom, I feel sick..."
My parents rushed to her side at once. Garrick grabbed her medication from the car, unscrewed a water bottle and held it to her lips.
The three of them hovered over her as though she were the only victim here.
I picked up the backpack Mom had dropped and found that the name tag was covered with a cartoon sticker.
I had barely peeled back one corner when Garrick pressed his hand over mine.
"That's enough. Aubrey is having an asthma attack. Can't you look after her first? How can you be so cold?"
"She has the three of you." I slowly pulled my hand back and looked at him with red-rimmed eyes. "I might have just lost my daughter."
To my disbelief, disappointment filled his eyes. "Opal Kirkland, I always thought you were hard, but today I realized you don't even have feelings for your own family."
His words were the final blow, severing what little attachment I had left.
On the day Clover was born, I hemorrhaged badly. Garrick left right before I went into surgery because Aubrey was making a scene about her divorce.
Afterward, he always said I was overthinking it.
Only now did I understand. They were the real family. Clover and I were simply the ones who could be sacrificed at any moment.
A police car pulled up at the intersection.
Before Garrick let go of me, he leaned close to my ear and warned, "Think carefully before you open your mouth. One word from you could ruin Aubrey's whole life."
I handed the backpack to an officer, wiped off the tears in the corners of my eyes and answered calmly and firmly. "Anyone who does something wrong should face the consequences."
Chapter 4
The police began examining the scene.
Aubrey insisted she had not been driving fast. She claimed the child had darted out from between two illegally parked cars, and that was what had caused the accident.
"Were you using your phone while driving?" an officer asked.
"No."
I handed over my backup phone. My voice was still hoarse, but I refused to back down. "When I first got here, she told me herself that she looked down at the GPS."
Aubrey went pale.
Dad immediately countered, "She was in shock. People say the wrong thing when they're scared. Opal and her sister have never gotten along, and she isn't thinking straight right now. You can't believe everything she says."
I looked at Dad, and my fingers trembled slightly.
He did not merely favor Aubrey. To protect her, he would even slander me in front of strangers.
The officer frowned. "We'll figure out who's lying. Where's the dashcam?"
Aubrey clutched Garrick's sleeve. "It broke a few days ago."
"That model uploads to the cloud automatically," I said coldly.
Aubrey's legs buckled.
Mom held her up and cried out at me. "You've already got the police ready to take her away. Isn't that enough? What more do you want? Even if it was Aubrey's fault, will sending her to prison bring that child back? The dead can't come back to life. The living are the ones who matter!"
Dad softened his tone as well. "Aubrey didn't mean to do it. Let it go this one time and the whole family will make it up to you."
Aubrey walked up to me and took my hand. "Opal, you can have my house. When I have my next baby, I'll have her call you Mom."
I yanked my hand away, my eyes burning. "So anyone can replace Clover, is that it?"
"That's not what I meant." She shook her head, crying.
"I love Clover too, but even if I go to prison, she won't come back. Can you really stand to watch Mom and Dad lose their granddaughter and then lose a daughter too?"
I stared at her and asked slowly, weighing every word, "So it's my daughter who gets sacrificed, and I'm the one who always has to swallow it and forgive?"
Garrick immediately stepped in front of Aubrey. "Opal, stop pushing her."
I suddenly remembered the year Clover fell into the water when she was five.
Aubrey had twisted her ankle on the bank while Clover struggled in the water. Garrick heard the cries for help, but he carried Aubrey to the first aid station first. By the time I pulled Clover out, she had swallowed so much water that her face had turned blue.
At the time, he said Aubrey had been closer to him, and that it was only an instinctive choice.
I looked at him and asked through my tears, "If the child lying there today were Bonnie, would you be telling her mother not to call the police?"
Garrick said nothing.
"If I had been the one driving and Aubrey were the one who died, would you protect me the way you're protecting her now?"
He still did not answer.
The last flicker of hope in my eyes finally went out.
Mom kept complaining. "Why do sisters have to keep score like this? We're heartbroken about Clover too, but life has to go on. Aubrey is alive, and she's the one we need to protect right now."
I slipped off my wedding ring and placed it in Garrick's palm.
His hand closed tightly around it. "What's that supposed to mean?"
"You're right. The living have to go on with their lives." I took two steps back, my voice calm and clear.
"That's why, starting today, I'm going on with mine without any of you."
"This isn't the time to talk about divorce!" Garrick snapped. "Once this is over and you've calmed down, we'll talk."
"I'm perfectly calm." I turned to my parents and straightened my back.
"From now on, whether Aubrey lives or dies has nothing to do with me. You can stop thinking of me as your daughter too. I'm the heartless one, remember?"
Mom's eyes reddened as she lashed out at me. "You would cut ties with every living relative over a child who's already dead?"
I was about to answer when a clear, familiar voice rang out from inside the school gate.
"Mommy, what took you so long to come get me?"