He Gave My Sister My Engagement Ring

My boyfriend, Carter, was a man obsessed with "milestones."

During our three years in a long-distance relationship, he would always prepare two surprise gifts for every birthday and anniversary.

One was for me, and the other was for my sister, Lily.

I used to think he was just being sweet, loving my family because he loved me.

But over those three years, the gifts I unwrapped were always cheap, ten-dollar plush keychains.

Meanwhile, Lily always got designer handbags and luxury jewelry.

Every time I saw Lily showing off her gifts on Instagram, I would make excuses for him.